Military Religious Freedom Foundation
Posted by Pellora in Defense, Politics, Relaxed Politics, US Politics
The Military Religious Freedom Foundation was established by Michael L. “Mikey” Weinstein.
I heard an interview this morning with Mikey Weinstein – He was engaging, forthright, passionate, and “militant” about protecting freedom of religion within the military and also outside the military whether in the United States or internationally.
I was completely impressed! I have long held that the take-over of the United States government by Fundamentalist Christians is very wrong and in many respects evil. I don’t like being labeled *not Christian enough* nor do I like it when others are also vilified. The hate toward non-Christians is truly evil. I had heard, and sometimes read (not often, funny how the MSM didn’t really cover this *evangelizing of the U.S. Military* much) about the attempts by officers to convert our soldiers. I did read about the Bible distribution in the Middle East where our soldiers are deployed, but even that story went away after only a brief exposure. The work that Mikey Weinstein is doing and the price he and his family is paying will surprise and shock you. He is really doing more than anyone to protect our Constitutional Freedom of Religion.
Mikey has a very good Foundation website, that gives a history which I will post portions of here, a page of the Foundation members, a page that links to current articles and interviews, plus other stuff. Please take the time to read about Mikey, his family, the problem in the military.
Religious Freedom and the Military: A Short History
The concept and practice of religious freedom in the United States Armed Forces date back to the earliest days of this nation. The United States Constitution outlines the basic concept of religious freedom as understood by Americans in the Bill of Rights. More specifically, the First Amendment to the Constitution specifies that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion. Or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…”
All branches of the United States military are afforded the same rights to religious freedom as are American civilians. However, members of the Armed Forces willingly surrender on a temporary basis certain free exercise rights when it impinges on military discipline and the successful completion of a military objective. This guarantee of religious freedom is codified for the Armed Forces in Title 10, United States Code (USC), sections 3073, 3547, 5142, and 8067. Free exercise of religious freedom for military personnel is further detailed in Department of Defense Directive (DODD) 1300.17, “Accommodation of Religious Practices Within the Military Services,” which describes the commander’s responsibility to provide for religious accommodation.
Religious freedom takes on an additional importance in the current international environment, where religious motivations are an increasing rationale for waging conflict. At a time when the United States is encouraging greater religious freedom in Muslim nations, it is imperative upon America to show by example that religious pluralism is a viable and preferred option. Any sign of hypocrisy in Unites States policy, official or otherwise, toward the free exercise of religion within the military makes it more difficult to convince others to follow our nation’s chosen path.
MRFF’s role is to ensure that our government does indeed adhere to the spirit as well as the letter of the Constitution; that it leads by example. The next chapter in the never-ending struggle to expand religious freedom in the military is being written, and MRFF is playing a critical part in the effort. A watchdog’s role requires constant vigilance.
In this article, entitled Religious intolerance at Wright Patt? Mikey Weinstein’s ‘militant’ foundation and his family think so., a specific case is discussed, but there is also a very good personal history of Mikey Weinstein.
Each year, more than one and a half million visitors stream through the National Museum of the U.S. Air Force at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base in Fairborn.Walking between the cavernous early flight and World War II hangars, tourists, veterans and school groups must pass through a replica of the main gate of Auschwitz and into Prejudice and Memory: A Mobile Holocaust Exhibit.
The exhibit, curated by local survivor Renate Frydman on behalf of the Dayton Holocaust Resource Center, has been on permanent display at the Air Force museum since 1999.
It is the museum’s way of illustrating why the United States goes to war: to defeat the tyranny that destroys human freedom.
But according to Mikey Weinstein, founder and president of the Military Religious Freedom Foundation — and his son and daughter-in-law Casey and Amanda Weinstein of Fairborn — Wright-Patterson Air Force base is a “hotbed” of “unconstitutional religious intolerance.”
On March 5, Weinstein’s foundation filed a comprehensive lawsuit against the Department of Defense. The lawsuit, filed with co-plaintiff U.S. Army Specialist Jeremy Hall, an atheist, alleges that while stationed in Iraq, Hall was the victim of retaliation and reprisal because of his views.
The foundation, which Weinstein himself describes as “militant” and “in your face,” aims to ensure that military personnel don’t use their official positions to endorse particular religious views on subordinates while on duty. This practice, Weinstein says, particularly by fundamentalist evangelical Christians in the U.S. military, is pervasive.
“It has nothing to do with their religious faith, it has to do with their trying to impose their religious faith using the draconian structure of the military command influence,” Weinstein says while visiting his son and daughter-in-law at their Fairborn home.
According to Weinstein, the 96 percent who are Christians seek help from the foundation because the message they receive from their military command is, “they’re not Christian enough.”
He established the foundation in 2004 as a result of the proselytizing and antisemitism his sons, Casey and Curtis, experienced as cadets at the Air Force Academy at Colorado Springs. Weinstein is also a graduate of the academy.
The foundation’s October 2004 suit against the Air Force Academy was ultimately thrown out because of a technicality.
On Feb. 9, 2006, the Air Force issued new guidelines on religious tolerance and practices for the Air Force and the academy.
“They’re just pretty words that mean nothing,” Weinstein said of the guidelines at the time.
Mikey Weinstein says the military has tried to prevent people from contacting his foundation.
Casey Weinstein adds that most are too scared to contact the foundation. He says that most proselytizing comes from officers. “The officers are the ones with the power. Even if an enlisted person has these beliefs, they don’t always have the power to force it on others. Officers do.”
McGowan points out that the Air Force cannot act until “Airmen or civilian employees come forward with specific factual allegations.”
These complaints, she writes, can be lodged at the Equal Opportunity Office, the Inspector General’s Office, the wing chapel or directly with a commander. “Officials at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base promptly investigate and take appropriate action in response to each complaint.”
“How can you use your chain of command when it’s completely and totally corroded?” Mikey Weinstein says.
On July 8, the U.S. Justice Department filed a motion to dismiss the foundation and Hall’s lawsuit on the grounds that Hall didn’t take his complaints to the chain of command and that Hall and the foundation lack standing to sue the Department of Defense.
Mikey Weinstein believes this case will ultimately go to the Supreme Court. “Right now, we lose 5-4 on our best day at the Supreme Court,” he says. “Besides our fight, the two greatest threats that are facing this country is the fact that John Paul Stevens is 88 and Ruth Bader Ginsburg is 75 and ailing. And oh my God. This country was not designed to have representative democracy supplanted by theocracy.”
Please read the whole article. It will amaze you, but not in a good way.
Mikey Weinstein has been in the news a lot lately – radio, teevee, print, internet.
Lawyer Sues to End Dallas Group’s ‘Threat’ Prayers
on godsownparty.com/blog which subtitles itself “Rebiblican Political Watch”
In looking at photos of President Obama during his unscheduled visit to Section 60 of Arlington National Cemetery, the area of Iraq and Afghanistan service men and women, I noticed that there were different symbols on the marble stones. So I looked it up. Here is the page that lists and shows the allowed emblems on stone monuments in Arlington National Cemetery. I remember that lawsuits resulted in the addition of the Wiccan and also the Atheist emblems. I think this information is good to know, but is also related to the work of the Military Religious Freedom Foundation. This is what the Foundation is fighting for, after all.
Tags: religion, Separation Of Church And State, US military
Entries (RSS)
Great post, Pellora. Another example of how far off the right track we are as a nation.
I answered your question about “in sickness and in health” downstairs. I didn’t want to go OT right away here.
@ gnome de plume:
And I answered you back down there for the same reason.
We got into a short discussion the other day that hit on religion and the military, separation of church and state, and similar issues. I had worked on this post by then, so refrained from elaborating.
The work that this Foundation is doing is immeasurably important. Everyone should be given the utmost respect when they have chosen to serve in the United States Military. And respecting their personal beliefs is key to respecting the person.
I believe that the tragic event at Fort Hood will have many repercussions, both in and out of the military. And this Foundation and their work will be important in coping with the event and aftermath. Many are already condemning non-Christian military personnel, and it seems to be a factor in this event. It makes no difference if it is a small factor, that fact that it was a part of it makes it important to consider.
I am sure there are other service men and women who are equally conflicted in war against people who are of similar background or religious faith. During war, *the other or the enemy* is always demonized, and the consequences of that are rarely investigated.
I’m thinking that such *demonization* will be investigated now. But war is evil, so I hold no real confidence that things will change.
Authorized Emblems in Arlington National Cemetery
@ Pellora:
Unfortunately, too many people get into issues such as “just wars” and who is to say?
If one truly believes the world is God’s creation, that in turn extends to everyone–differences and all. I know that people want to share their faith(s) but I don’t like being hit over the head with someone else’s beliefs. There is a song that says “They will know we are Christians by our love.” Not words, but acts. That’s a far cry from the evangelical Christian theology I see in others.
The chaplain service in the miliatary in the past was non-denominational for Christians other than Catholics (who had a priest). Not sure what was done for other religions, although some claimed their power and recognition (Wiccan).
Ugh, winter has arrived. Rain all day and it is now getting colder and snow is predicted for tonight. (No Minnesota proportions tonight, however
)
Off to my Monday evening dinner group.
Please solve this issue while I am out.
Symbols of Faith
Not related specifically to this post, but of the military, mental health, and definitely related to Cassie’s recent observations -
Dr. Kernan Manion is a Real Hero.
Camp Lejeune whistle-blower fired
A psychiatrist who tried to prevent Fort Hood-style violence among Marines about to “lose it” instead loses his job
A more recent story of Alexis Hutchinson Spc. Alexis Hutchinson, 21, claims she had no choice but to refuse deployment orders because the only family she had to care for her 10-month-old son
Broken, I tell you. Our military and our country are broken.
@ Pellora:
That Salon article on the Camp Lejeune psychiatrist needs to be spread far and wide. Our military is so broken. Here is the closing of the article:
@ gnome de plume:
Very much so. I am hopeful that it will be spread around. Maybe we should do a post on it – or should I say “I” ? Then maybe it will get a little exposure by blog reading and such and searches.
@ Pellora:
I was thinking the same thing – we should do a post on this “damned if you do, damned if you don’t” business – especially in light of having at least one Bum among us who is extremely sensitive to the plight of the military.
@ gnome de plume:
you or me?
Poor NAFG
Pellora wrote:
Let me have a go at it real quick. I won’t do all the research and links you usually do, though. I’ll put it back stage and you can add to it. How about that???
Pellora wrote:
Hopefully he loses to the Democrat in the general election.
Hey y’all. I am alive and well but spending the evening with a friend. Her issues, not mine. All is good. Don’t finish up the ice cream!
@ gnome de plume:
oops, catch the Gnome. I did one already…. but I’ll check them both out!
@ gnome de plume:
I
‘ll combinecombined themand put two names on thereand marked it as pending under your gnome!Pellora:
OK. It is all yours, or mine, or ours. I am off to
and watch KO.
Yeah, last night’s game was a piece of crap to wake up to. I haven’t yet seen a good account of how it turned around. But I’m more upset with the Bruins, who are in some weird kind of slump – they’re playing well, but can’t get anything past the opposing goalie.
Do I have to go down to Beantown and kick some f****** *ss??!
Pellora, re downstairs: I’m the wrong gender representative to ask. I’m the one who ends up taking care of things, (people, pets …). I’m looking forward to being able to retire from that activity. Only taking “obligations” at the current time, and you better have a DNA test to prove it!
Whoa! I disappeared for an hour and a half and nothing happened here!
Where is everybody???
@ gordon:
I was horrified.
Wish I could get more hockey games on the tube. They don’t air many around here.
Belichick made a really, really stupid call.
Hey y’all!
Busy doing stuff, and things, and such. Throw a bit of family drama into the mix, plus a lost “toof” and a discussion over whether the bill the Tooth fairy leaves will have a 1 or a 5 on it
It’s been quite a day.
@ gordon:
Yes, you do need to yell louder. You’re way the hell up there in Maine, how else would they hear you??
@ madmommy:
a 1 or a 5? My, how inflation has set in!
(Which kid was it who lost da toof?)
@ Gnome de Plume:
I’m just passing through. Have an extra early morning, so you have the blog to yourself. Enjoy!
Oh, the only positive news I was able to discern today is that Castle (R-Delaware), who comes from a political dynasty (of moderate R’s) and was immensely popular, has had his ratings drop like 40 points because of his (R-conforming) votes. TPM had this earlier.
‘Course, there’s a lesson in there for certain Progressives. But the ones who need to hear it, won’t. Sigh.
It is already down to 44 tonight!
It is supposed to be in the 30’s by morning
That is cold around here. We haven’t had a frost yet, and it isn’t predicted for tonight, but I brought the rest of my orchids in anyway. The heat will prolly come on tonight for the first time this season!
@ gordon:
Goodnight! I may turn in earlier than usual as well. I want to get in a good bunch of hours at the orchid ranch tomorrow and I have a haircut appointment at 1:00.
@ gnome de plume:
The little guy, of course! This is his 3rd lost “toof”, he swallowed the first one with some crunchy Cheetos on a road trip, the second one came out with an apple. The fairy gives a buck a tooth, unless you’re at teh grandparents house, then you get more. The big kid and his girl cousin both got a C-note from my dad for losing their first tooth, but the little guy got bupkis.
He’s got some moxie, that kid. I told him he had to put the tooth under his pillow and there would be money there in the morning. He asked what kind of money, and I said a dollar. He then asked if those are the ones that have a 5 on them
But then this is the kid, when grandpa was peeling singles off his money clip for something or other, told his grandpa to fold the money back up so he could have one of those dollars with the zero’s on it. He had an empty pocket, see, and needed something to put in it.
@ madmommy:
OMG! There is such a thing as a toof fairy!
A C-note???
My big kid is a shark. His new teeth come in and THEN the old one falls out.
@ gordon:
I’m here now. I was prepping an invoice to get it sent off so the $$ can come back! A priority!
@ gnome de plume:
I noticed you were gone a long time, and no one else was here, so for a change I didn’t talk to myself.
So much for 25 or 50 cents a tooth with my kidlets. I don’t even remember what the toof fairy brought me. Sheesh.
@ gnome de plume:
My dad likes to flash cash. What pisses me off is he did it for the other two grandkids and totally blew off the little guy. It’s not the first time, he did it again at Halloween and I’m still pretty pissed about it. The little guy has no idea, of course. But if he can con his granddad out of some extra cash, more power to him, I say!
@ Lea:
That’s just freaky! My kid’s teeth are loose forever before they finally fall out! The little guy’s top front teeth are both loose and show no signs of actually coming out of his head. When they do, they’ll probably go together.
Here you go, footballcrazybums
@ gnome de plume:
Pel, I left a thought down below on Betsy’s thread regarding commitment.
I’m with ya, and everyone, who believes in separation of church n state and military.
I’ve read tons of stuff about Xtian’s in the Army, and mostly in the AIR FORCE, and the trials of them lost nukes a few years ago.
Xtian’s have WAY too much of an influence on our Air Force, that has control of and access to, our nukes.
Can this be changed? I’m not so sure anymore.
I’m really challenged that we the people can get control of our country, its issues, and it’s future.
I think of we don’t get SOME thing from this present Presidency, and more in ‘12, we’re screwed into a big brother scheme that separates rich from poor. Forevah.
@ madmommy:
The vet pulled one of the pup’s baby teeth out of concern for misalignment
Yeah, I remembered that Halloween incident when you mentioned the big kid and the girl cousin. I’m pissed off at him and he’s not even my father.
@ Lea:
I had a couple of puppies whose teeth did that.
TexLittleKid got a dollar from us or a $10 from the toooth fairy that lives on Cloud 9 above Grandma’s house. Had to write to THAT tooth fairy though.
@ Pellora:
Feh, Belichick is an ass, always has been, always will be. He, his raggedy-assed hoodie and his cheating ways can go piss up a rope. I cannot wait till they come to the Dome in 2 weeks for a Monday night game. The Patsies do not have that invincible mojo they flaunted in recent years. Maybe it was getting caught cheating, maybe it was Brady’s injury, who knows.
Once, the kid lost a tooth at the pool in the 9 foot water and had to leave an explanation under the pillow instead of a tooth.
@ Texas Betsy:
Heh, the ice cream has been slathered with Bailey’s Irish Cream, and it’s all been slathered upon chocolate chip cookies fresh out of the oven you left baking.
Burp!!!!!!!
Ahhhhh.
Oh, we cleaned up best we could.
@ Gnome de Plume:
Next to soccer, Internationale, I can’t think of a more boring sport.
ICING!!!!
Or do they still call that nuance?
Booooorrrriiiiinnnnngggggg!
@ larue:
Thanks. Commitment and loyalty!
And yummy Bailey’s icecream and cookies!
And I gathered that Bellichick is an ass. And the
from cheating – he gotz it! Injury could fit into that picture too ya know.
Now the weather service says we could have a light freeze in low lying areas. I knew the temperature was dropping too fast. I set the heat to come on in the house. That first blast is always nasty – all the burning dust from the summer, and we had a lot of dust this summer. We still have it from the road work being done in the ‘hood. Every morning my car is covered with a layer of red dirt.
@ madmommy:
Yer gonna take this loss heavily.
Alas.
Still, I hope you’ll treat the Beach Hauz Bumz with the MODICUM of respect, you’ve expected us to treat the Saints.
*G*
@ Pellora:
Sounds like the guys who hang out at the beach house are not your run of the mill type guys!
I am going to turn in. I want to try to get up early. Found a couple of books on the shelf that look promising.
@ Pellora:
Bellachik is gawd, and he will smite the Saints Dat Won’t Go Marchin IN.
And if Bellachik don’t, Brady will.
*G*
@ larue:
The way I look at it is I’d rather they lost a game during the season than try to keep up the pressure of a perfect season through to the playoffs or the Super Bowl. As I recall, that didn’t work out so good for the Pats a year or so ago. Undefeated all the way to the Super Bowl only to lose the final game of the year is truly sucky
Especially losing to a team like the Giants who everyone said had not a snowball’s chance in hell of winning that game. IIRC, Betsy was happydancing for a week!
not a barrel of laughs though…
@ Pellora:
That is NOT a happy birthday cartoon!
OK, I’m outta here
Hi honeys I am finally home.
Anyone make it over to chat salon?
@ Texas Betsy:
I didn’t know how to get their without your linkie. I checked a bit ago thinking I might have missed your linkie
A little (not so light) reading of The Decision Monday 16 November 2009 by: William Rivers Pitt, t r u t h o u t | Columnist
from backstage search comments for “bluegal” and “chat”
Rethink Afghanistan
@ Texas Betsy:
Duh
Sherrod Brown and other progressive senators held a meeting Monday night with Harry Reid to let the majority leader know they don’t intend to give up any more of an already weakened public option.
pellora, want to choose an overnight thread? and perhaps decide which one back there would be best for daytime tomorrow.
Thanks again to all who are pitching in.
@ Texas Betsy:
oh. I’ll go see.
@ Texas Betsy:
Cigar overnight. Damned tomorrow.
Gnome’s Cigar upstairs.